Dr Alex Monegal (Barcelona, Spain) Clinica Diagonal

Edit Post

Quote from: YourSpaceBoyfriend on October 25, 2016, 10:22:44 AMIt's purely based on people experience. I'm mostly comparing fitbone to precise 2/gnail
Height loss and need of additional surgery.
And as far as i know Precise 2 can at least weight bear as twice as much.

I think i don't need to be qualified to be entitled to my personal opinion don't you think?
The latest diary of a precise2 patient reported a malfunction in the nail which had to be replaced. Just saying.

Edit Post

NoRegrets you don't know what you're saying. I'm not Lluser and the case you are talking about has nothing to do with Fitbone failures. In Penguins case the nail failed in OR and was replaced immediately in the same OR (no need of extra surgery). However, when Fitbone has failed in the past it has failed in OR and they had no replacement for the poor patient (not Penguin's case) or it failed when the patient had done 1 cm or 5 cm and needed several extra surgeries. It has failed many times according to patients themselves. The doctor said to his future patients it never failed and that's the reason why Lluser and other people exposed him here.

Edit Post

Dear Users

Of Course You are not Lluser.
As To clarify with The implant subject:

In my experience I had no case of implant failure until The case You refer To. The only thing I explained To my patients was The statistic given To me by The manufacturer (12 failures in more than 2000 Fitbone 4 Implants).

About implant choice:

I have explained several times The perfect implant does not exist. There are things about Precice I prefer from The Fitbone, and things from The Fitbone I prefer from The precice. In my opinion I prefer The Fitbone because It s not just a nail, we have bone transport nail (not available with precice) and we can adapt The system To a prosthesis (in case of bone tumour).
I have been offered To use Precice (They offered me 10% profit) and I refused. WITTENSTEIN surgeons do not get any profit prom The companys.
On top of that, I have no experience with precice and You can read in Acta Ortopedica about The reliability of Precice.

https://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pmc/articles/PMC4062798/

About G nail It s based On Albizzia Nail. This Is way back in The implant evolution When compared with Fitbone OR Precice. Guichet Is an outstanding surgeon and he Is confident with his system. I think that at The end The system Should be a surgeon's choice based On their experience and How confident They feel about It.

About weigthbearing:

Problem with load Is that all The weigth relies in The locking screws during The first 8-10 weeks of distraction. This can cause screw loosening Or bending. I have seen tests On fitbones done with 200kg load and Implant was working after that. The screw issue Is for ANY internal implant.


Lluser said a lot of things. More than 300 posts..even saying one of The patients in The guesthouse died because of femur fracture. The other guy posted pictures of amputated People. You can defend that, But in my opinion This Should never be published in The forum because It s not true and shows a lack of respect and credibility from The user and from The forum ítself.
Cheers

Edit Post

Quote from: Lgazer on October 25, 2016, 02:34:36 PMNoRegrets you don't know what you're saying. I'm not Lluser and the case you are talking about has nothing to do with Fitbone failures. In Penguins case the nail failed in OR and was replaced immediately in the same OR (no need of extra surgery). However, when Fitbone has failed in the past it has failed in OR and they had no replacement for the poor patient (not Penguin's case) or it failed when the patient had done 1 cm or 5 cm and needed several extra surgeries. It has failed many times according to patients themselves. The doctor said to his future patients it never failed and that's the reason why Lluser and other people exposed him here.
I know exactly what I am saying and what I said its the truth.

You expect people to believe you when you're clearly lying when you say that you're not LLuser1. TIBIKE already said that you write the same way as LLuser1 and infact you do. Not just the way you write but what you write is exactly the same.

As if this isn't enough to prove you're LLuser1, Lgazer account was created during your first ban and suddenly stopped posting on the 29th ofMay. 29th of May is the day that LLuser1 got his account back and started posting again. LLuser1 is banned a 2nd time mid October and Lgazer is back in the same week as LLuser1 is banned, again.

I'm used to be polite but dude, just go fk yourself with all your lies.

Edit Post

Quote from: Dr Monegal on October 25, 2016, 03:03:59 PMDear Users

Of Course You are not Lluser.
As To clarify with The implant subject:

In my experience I had no case of implant failure until The case You refer To. The only thing I explained To my patients was The statistic given To me by The manufacturer (12 failures in more than 2000 Fitbone 4 Implants).

About implant choice:

I have explained several times The perfect implant does not exist. There are things about Precice I prefer from The Fitbone, and things from The Fitbone I prefer from The precice. In my opinion I prefer The Fitbone because It s not just a nail, we have bone transport nail (not available with precice) and we can adapt The system To a prosthesis (in case of bone tumour).
I have been offered To use Precice (They offered me 10% profit) and I refused. WITTENSTEIN surgeons do not get any profit prom The companys.
On top of that, I have no experience with precice and You can read in Acta Ortopedica about The reliability of Precice.

https://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pmc/articles/PMC4062798/

Hmm, the study is about the first generation of Precise doe.

Edit Post

Sorry man Noregrets you don't know what you're talking about. I posted in May, then I was out of the forum for 2 months but came back in August! Not in October. Your theory doesn't work. I haven't posted much but I have been again in the forums from August and you can check some of my posts then. I have the same opinion than LLuser in many things but I have never copy pasted

So Monegal how many implants failed? why didn't you have a replacement as Parihar did? Why did this persons have so many surgeries if Fitbone can be tested in OR? And then how many screws got loose? I have heard many patients got screws loose (50%).

Edit Post

Quote from: YourSpaceBoyfriend on October 25, 2016, 03:16:58 PMHmm, the study is about the first generation of Precise doe.

If you read studies about first generation Fitbone they are much worse! All good surgeons know that first fitbone didn't work at all. Precise is way better. It's my opinion doe

Edit Post

Quote from: Lgazer on October 25, 2016, 03:21:24 PMSorry man Noregrets you don't know what you're talking about. I posted in May, then I was out of the forum for 2 months but came back in August! Not in October. Your theory doesn't work. I haven't posted much but I have been again in the forums from August and you can check some of my posts then. I have the same opinion than LLuser in many things but I have never copy pasted

So Monegal how many implants failed? why didn't you have a replacement as Parihar did? Why did this persons have so many surgeries if Fitbone can be tested in OR? And then how many screws got loose? I have heard many patients got screws loose (50%).
No you didn't come back in August. you had 3 post on 7th August but thats about it. It's funny that even with all this evidence you still deny it.

Edit Post

Quote from: Lgazer on October 25, 2016, 03:21:24 PMSo Monegal how many implants failed? why didn't you have a replacement as Parihar did? Why did this persons have so many surgeries if Fitbone can be tested in OR? And then how many screws got loose? I have heard many patients got screws loose (50%).Actually that is Ellipse's policy not Dr. Parihar's. They usually ship 3 sets of nails at once.

And I do think you're LLUser1, not many people call him Monegal instead of Dr. Monegal.

Edit Post

Ehh and again this topic turned to be LLuser circlejerk.

Screw it, i'm done with monegal oriented topics.