Doctors with bad reputation on this forum

Edit Post

I’ve been reading this forum quite a bit to get information and so far have had one face to face consultation with an LL surgeon and a Skype consultation with another LL surgeon .

From the posts on this forum, I’ve noticed the following doctors all have a bad reputation on here but are still in business, appear all to be busy still with a good number of patients and with successful cases (although for Dr Monegal I don’t know if this is the case). They are:

Dr Sarin

Dr Monegal

Dr Mirzoyan

Dr Guichet

Dr Betz

My question is, are these doctors really not to be trusted because of some of some bad cases. Which of these would you consider the worst??

I might not get any reply be would be interesting  to see what I might get.

Edit Post

Quote from: cool on January 22, 2019, 10:00:04 AMYou are really not getting anywhere with these posts. No one knows the answer.

You have to make up your mind and go with a doctor you felt right during an in-person consultation.

And asking for the best doctor would make some sense, but you're asking for the worst 

Hehe I suppose it is strange to be asking who is the worst!! Lol 😆

Edit Post

Quote from: patientprivacy on January 22, 2019, 01:10:07 PMI don't know about the others but Dr Monegal is active and busy with a good number of succesful cases. If he has a bad reputation here it's because of Lluser and his army of accounts. Notatroll is a fake.

May I ask why a number of users here say he’s fake?? I’ve noticed that previously. Why has his experience not been taken seriously here like for example some of the others who have noted very bad experiences? I’m just curious.

Edit Post

Quote from: hanshi on January 22, 2019, 11:35:49 AMIt doesn't have much to do with whether a doctor just has had a few bad cases. The issue is whether the doctor can be trusted or not. And that is something which cannot be found out by just having a consultation, because it is easy for a doctor to lie during a consultation. Therefore it is rather save to say that were there is smoke there is a fire. The doctors mentioned above all have "earned" their bad reputation not just due to some bad outcomes, but because they betrayed the trust of their patients.
As a general rule it is save to say that most surgeons who practice cosmetic LL belong to the lowest category of surgeons with regards to ethics as well as skills. There might be a few exceptions but those mentioned above certainly aren't.

At least 1 or 2 of these doctors on the initial list also operate on children and help people with various deformities where cosmetic work is only some of the work they do. So it cannot be that unethical if you combine the work you do.

I am not sure of some doctors do mostly just CLL. It's not clear. It must depend where you are. I would imagine in India, there will not be a short supply of CLL patients.

Edit Post

I have just checked Dr Monegal’s prices. He is cheap. External device very cheap and internal also quite cheap. But I would be too scared to go there. I have a bad feeling about this doctor.

Unless I misunderstood how he charges.