lets have a fun activity for the insane asylum today
everyone rank every doctor you feel like you know anything about, you can explain or not explain your rankings
S tier: paley, assayag, rozbruch
A tier: mahboubian, giotikas, Becker
B Tier: Debiparshad, Guichet
C tier: Parihar
F. Halil Buldu, Sedat, Sarin
This is just my general idea, dont take this too serious as im not super well informed on most doctors
Quote from: stretched on February 13, 2023, 04:31:21 PM
Mahboubian and Debipashard seem a little sketchy to me IMO. I'm sure they are both skilled surgeons, but they both give off salesmen vibes and they seem to downplay how major of a surgery this really is. They also advertise CLL as their main practice, which is not really what you want. I don't really know too much about them though so I will refrain further judgement
I agree with this, however I feel mahboubian is still better than debiparshad as atlaseast mahboubian has many good outcomes and diaries, while debiparshad apparently lies about how many surgeries he's done. I dont think mahboubian downplays the surgery/ recovery timespan as much as Debiparshad
Quote from: Body Builder on February 14, 2023, 11:08:38 PMAnd many tragic cases too. Also fitbone is the most unreliable nail ever so any doctor that still uses it is a big no for me.
Also I can't understand why some of you rank Guichet anything more than the worst tier.
The money he wants are almost the same as Paley, who is the best LL doctor in the world, and had many terrific cases that we only hear in third world countries.
For me only a fool would give so much money to go Guichet.
And also Becker is a new doctor in LL. Of course he can't be a top tier compared to trauma doctors with much experience like Giotikas, Pili etc.
And finally, merchants like Derbipashad can't be top tier for that and only, even if they are good doctors which I doubt because top.doctors don't need merchandise.
In a few words, I completely disagree with most of the lists above.
Becker learned from Betz for many many years, he's new in being the one running the practice but as far as I remember he's been there like 6-10 years? Which yeah, he's not paley/rozbruch level, but im sure he's still good enough.
The more I learn about giotikas it seems like he's the best option for those of us who aren't rich. He offers a weight bearing nail and his price is not ridiculous. Obviously its smarter to go with paley or rozbruch, but for some people including me we cant bear to continue living our lives like this, so ill get one lengthening with him in the next few years.
I didnt rank birkholtz or Solomin because I haven't read anything on either of them.
You must be logged in to post a reply.