Dr Parihar vs Dr Monegal

Edit Post

Monegal can get Precice, however, the price cant be the same as the nails cost more.

Edit Post

Monegal can get Precice, however, the price cant be the same as the nails cost more.

Edit Post

Yes., the rod can stay in forever. That's just a fact. You can ask a surgeon if you wish

I was not going to have the rod removed, but removing the screws will perhaps make my ankle a bit less stiff. Not 100% positive, but since  rod removal  is a very minor surgery with very minimal risk, might as well get it done to see if anything improves.

I'm in New York btw and could have the surgery done here since  Insurance would cover it. It is a very minor  procedure.  I want to visit Barcelona for personal reasons, so might as well  kill 2 birds with 1 stone.

You are very annoying, and like to be rude on the internet. I find you very boring and tedious.   You have never met me, and  know nothing about me. You seem to imply that I  can't say the truth,  which would come as a big surprise to everyone that knows me

Furthermore, my diary contradicts this narrative. I posted negatively about Monegal  WHILE I WAS IN  HIS HOSPITAL WITH A BROKEN LEG. Yet, somehow even though I'm now a few thousand miles away and   walking, I can't post the truth out of fear.

You obviously have some kind of obsession with Monegal. Perhaps you have  valid reasons, but I don't give a   about your issues.

I don't care what  you say about Monegal , but don't act as if you   know me or have any knowledge of my  condition other than  what I post.


Quote from: notimportant on February 21, 2017, 01:33:08 AMYou`re full of contradictions. If the rod can stay forever why do you want it to be removed? You said you are having the rod removed by Monegal in June. So you need to be in good terms with him to get a good price ... and nobody wants to be in bad terms withe the surgeon who will operate on them. Cooper went to a different doctor so he didn't depend on him anymore. Let's wait until rods are removed and people can tell the truth. For the moment I wouldn't trust Fibone and Monegal

Edit Post

Yes., the rod can stay in forever. That's just a fact. You can ask a surgeon if you wish

I was not going to have the rod removed, but removing the screws will perhaps make my ankle a bit less stiff. Not 100% positive, but since  rod removal  is a very minor surgery with very minimal risk, might as well get it done to see if anything improves.

I'm in New York btw and could have the surgery done here since  Insurance would cover it. It is a very minor  procedure.  I want to visit Barcelona for personal reasons, so might as well  kill 2 birds with 1 stone.

You are very annoying, and like to be rude on the internet. I find you very boring and tedious.   You have never met me, and  know nothing about me. You seem to imply that I  can't say the truth,  which would come as a big surprise to everyone that knows me

Furthermore, my diary contradicts this narrative. I posted negatively about Monegal  WHILE I WAS IN  HIS HOSPITAL WITH A BROKEN LEG. Yet, somehow even though I'm now a few thousand miles away and   walking, I can't post the truth out of fear.

You obviously have some kind of obsession with Monegal. Perhaps you have  valid reasons, but I don't give a   about your issues.

I don't care what  you say about Monegal , but don't act as if you   know me or have any knowledge of my  condition other than  what I post.


Quote from: notimportant on February 21, 2017, 01:33:08 AMYou`re full of contradictions. If the rod can stay forever why do you want it to be removed? You said you are having the rod removed by Monegal in June. So you need to be in good terms with him to get a good price ... and nobody wants to be in bad terms withe the surgeon who will operate on them. Cooper went to a different doctor so he didn't depend on him anymore. Let's wait until rods are removed and people can tell the truth. For the moment I wouldn't trust Fibone and Monegal

Edit Post

btw crimson, now that you are in a much more calmed state (I can only imagine in what state you were before... considering amputation and all...), how is your feeling towards this surgery and all this height obssesion?
  You can answer me via pm if you wish

Edit Post

Quote from: notimportant on February 20, 2017, 10:18:09 PMHow many of you have had your nail removed and don't need the doctor anymore? None. You still here because you depend on him.

The difference with other doctors is Dr Monegal is monitoring the forum all day. Other doctors don't care and you can take their patients' opinions more seriously.

Dear LLuser,

You sound like nail removal is a risky operation but any skilled trauma doctor can do it. If he was a bad doctor we wouldnt even have the nail removed by him.
Furthermore, if I was Dr. Monegal I'd probably be thanking you because due to your false accusations, 8 patients felt the need to defend their doctor from you and by doing that you created a thread that in just 2 pages doctor Monegal has 100% positive feedback from 8 patients. Hard to find elsewhere.

Next time you try to defame a doctor by badmouthing him and his patients, make sure it doesn't back fire.

Edit Post

Quote from: notimportant on February 20, 2017, 10:18:09 PMHow many of you have had your nail removed and don't need the doctor anymore? None. You still here because you depend on him.

The difference with other doctors is Dr Monegal is monitoring the forum all day. Other doctors don't care and you can take their patients' opinions more seriously.

Are you aware of the inconsistency of your statements? By your logic then, all the patients who still depend on their doctor would defend him so as not to annoy him. So why would Crimsontide, in the past while in Barcelona and depended much more on Dr. Monegal, criticise him then? And now that he has become more, not less, independent of Dr. Monegal (as he is in NY), why would he defend him and return to him now?

And what about all the Paley, Guichet and Parihar patients who still depend on their doctor? Are you saying they are also lying so as not to annoy their doctor?

You further say that this is because of all the doctors, only Dr. Monegal monitors the forum and imply that this is a threat to the patients' independence to comment. If that is so, why would Dr. Monegal accept Crimsontide as a patient again?

Has it ever occurred to you that it would be good for a doctor to care about his patients' opinions of him?

Edit Post

I'd never choose Dr Monegal after all the real bad criticism, some very bad private opinions (the patients are scared to post) and some Xrays I've seen in private but your legs your decision. Good night

Edit Post

Quote from: notimportant on February 21, 2017, 11:57:43 AMI'd never choose Dr Monegal after all the real bad criticism, some very bad private opinions (the patients are scared to post) and some Xrays I've seen in private but your legs your decision. Good night

Its not your statements that bother people. It's your lack of proof. If you had proof people here would be thanking you and we would indeed see Monegal as a red flag.

But you are just saying stuff without any solid proof. I can do the same about any doctor. When we ask for proof you say to look at past diaries of other limb lengtheners. But if those same people are now saying they are happy now, then you dismiss that too.

It's like you are biased. Anything bad about monegal you take it in and anything good about him  you just filter out and choose to ignore.

I could just as easily say the same stuff about Paley and just look for bad stuff about him and ignore the good stuff. I could do that with anybody but if I don't have actual solid proof like videos x-rays pictures, then people would dismiss my claims and rightfully so.

Everything you say is suspect because lack of proof. You say that you have seen x-rays. But that's not proof. That's just you making a statement

Edit Post

I have noticed a lot of people mentioning the need for proof. Ok. Lets all take a look at the proof.

Proof...Cooper had to go to Dr. Rozbrusch and Dr. Paley after surgery with Dr. Monegal ruined his legs and almost turned him into a cripple. I have posted the link to his patient experience and his personal quotes. But what the hell, why not just post it again so everyone can see the proof.

Proof....http://www.limblengtheningforum.com/index.php?topic=2454.msg51176#msg51176

Proof...Musicmaker is still living life in a wheelchair after YEARS of being under the "care" of Dr. Monegal. Do not forget she lied about how bad her condition was until the PROOF was overwhelming that Dr. Monegal ruined her legs and she is living life like a cripple. Nothing screams stay away from this doctor more than a patient lying about their awful condition to protect the doctor.

So go ahead and have your surgery with Dr. Monegal. You will love all the money you are saving and you will feel all warm and fuzzy inside knowing that because it is Europe you are safe. As I have said before, that is exactly what Cooper and Musicmaker thought, and we know how that turned out thanks to all the PROOF...