Some questions about proportions

Edit Post

Hi,
I’ve seen a few different ratios for tibia to femur batted around here, but I can’t really find any concrete information on when it is your proportions start to look strange.

I’ll be doing Tibias. Does anyone have any links or formulas that are useful?

Thanks!

Edit Post

Doing tibia only is kind of stupid in my opinion. Why? Well it heals slower, has a higher complication rate, more likely to have permanant problems with joins / early arthiris, breaking 2 bones instead of 1, and most importantly you can gain much less height safetly (5 cm MAX vs 8 cm MAX). And for the love of god, don't do LON unless you want to the big risk of ostemylisis. Sorry for my gramma right now busy.

https://pubmed.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/26398436/

see 11:50 - 14:40

Edit Post

Overdoing tibias will make you look like a gazelle, overdoing femurs will make you look like a caterpillar.

Limit yourself to a tibia:femur ratio of 1 (you're probably at about 0.8 now).  Even that is kind of pushing it but it's still acceptable as long as you wear shorter shirts that don't cover much of your hips/thighs.  Looks better than wearing a big baggy shirt that could almost be a dress anyway.

And don't take this paranoid guy too seriously.  I did 7.5 cm (for the 1 ratio) on tibias with LON and never even got a superficial pinsite infection.  How you take care of yourself makes a big difference; this is not a random gamble.

Edit Post

most people could handle 7cm in one segment without looking strange, specially in femurs. don't go over that and it will be ok.

Edit Post

Quote from: Medium Drink Of Water on June 03, 2023, 05:04:07 PMOverdoing tibias will make you look like a gazelle, overdoing femurs will make you look like a caterpillar.

Limit yourself to a tibia:femur ratio of 1 (you're probably at about 0.8 now).  Even that is kind of pushing it but it's still acceptable as long as you wear shorter shirts that don't cover much of your hips/thighs.  Looks better than wearing a big baggy shirt that could almost be a dress anyway.

And don't take this paranoid guy too seriously.  I did 7.5 cm (for the 1 ratio) on tibias with LON and never even got a superficial pinsite infection.  How you take care of yourself makes a big difference; this is not a random gamble.

Cheers for the advice! I am indeed 0.8 right now at 5’8.5 evening height. What about sitting height? Is that something to factor into the equation?

Edit Post

Quote from: KrP1 on June 03, 2023, 09:33:34 PMmost people could handle 7cm in one segment without looking strange, specially in femurs. don't go over that and it will be ok.

Understood, thanks!

Edit Post

Quote from: DanishViking on June 03, 2023, 01:11:30 PMDoing tibia only is kind of stupid in my opinion. Why? Well it heals slower, has a higher complication rate, more likely to have permanant problems with joins / early arthiris, breaking 2 bones instead of 1, and most importantly you can gain much less height safetly (5 cm MAX vs 8 cm MAX). And for the love of god, don't do LON unless you want to the big risk of ostemylisis. Sorry for my gramma right now busy.

https://pubmed.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/26398436/

see 11:50 - 14:40

Thanks for the post, but that paper doesn’t really tell us a lot. What about the ones that show arthritis as a risk for femoral lengthening? https://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pmc/articles/PMC8231406/

I’d be doing pure externals anyway, but Giotikas himself told me that LON was a safe proceedure.

Edit Post

Quote from: LG1816 on June 04, 2023, 11:13:16 AMI’d be doing pure externals anyway, but Giotikas himself told me that LON was a safe proceedure.

A much better choice than LON.  It was my first choice but for a couple of reasons beyond my control, that didn't end up happening.

Edit Post

Quote from: Medium Drink Of Water on June 03, 2023, 05:04:07 PMOverdoing tibias will make you look like a gazelle, overdoing femurs will make you look like a caterpillar.

Limit yourself to a tibia:femur ratio of 1 (you're probably at about 0.8 now).  Even that is kind of pushing it but it's still acceptable as long as you wear shorter shirts that don't cover much of your hips/thighs.  Looks better than wearing a big baggy shirt that could almost be a dress anyway.

And don't take this paranoid guy too seriously.  I did 7.5 cm (for the 1 ratio) on tibias with LON and never even got a superficial pinsite infection.  How you take care of yourself makes a big difference; this is not a random gamble.

If someone has perfect ratio of around 0.80-0.82. Wouldnt a femur lengthening of 5 cm ruin it and put it below 0.80? Is it not better to do a tibia lengthening in that case and get a ratio of around 0.90?

Because for me currently I would guess I have around 0.80 ratio (havent done xrays yet) but I do care about the aesthetics aswell and I read that long tibias > long femurs from aesthetic view. What do you think?

I dont wanna end up looking strange

Edit Post

Quote from: LG1816 on June 04, 2023, 11:09:58 AMWhat about sitting height? Is that something to factor into the equation?

I would only pay attention to sitting height if I were doing more than one LL.