MEDICAL DISCLAIMER: The information provided on OrthoLength Pro is for educational purposes only and does not substitute for professional medical advice. Always consult with a qualified orthopedic surgeon.
Posted on Aug 25, 2014, 10:22 pm
#1
I already have quite a long thread in this forum already, but I wanted to ask this specific question in a separate thread.

I was having a discussion with my parents about eating and the subject got onto breakfast. I regularly would never have any breakfast, between the ages of about 12 and 18. During the school day, my lunch consisted of a few sandwiches, a bag of crisps and some biscuits/some chocolate. I'm actually amazed I could concentrate at school. Evening meals would vary but usually a decent sized portion with meat and some carbs. So I regularly went from 7pm one day, to 12pm the next day without any food. I also didn't drink milk during these years either, nor would I eat many (if any) fruit and veg, if that's any relevance.

Your body obviously gets accustomed to a pattern. At the time, I don't remember feeling that bad, but maybe I was a bit under-nourished? Maybe it affected my growth? My parents don't think it caused any loss of growth. They said they encouraged me to eat breakfast but I didn't want to, and they didn't force me. I've even asked a doctor before but they said I fall within the average range so it's no concern (also they said there's no way of knowing if I could have grown more).

Honestly how much do you think something like this affected my growth? Even if it didn't necessarily affect my height, could it have affected other areas? Any other information you need, feel free to ask. How much do you think this affected my growth?
Like (0)
Posted on Aug 25, 2014, 10:28 pm
#2
To stunt growth you have to be malnourished. Think skinny kids with bones showing type malnourished.
You were fine.
Like (0)
Posted on Aug 25, 2014, 10:37 pm
#3
Quote from: theuprising on August 25, 2014, 10:28:00 PM
To stunt growth you have to be malnourished. Think skinny kids with bones showing type malnourished.
You were fine.

Yeah you're right, I wasn't malnourished, but surely it must have had SOME effect on my growth?

For what it's worth, I remember getting weighed at age 15 - I was only 105 lbs (about 48kg). At 17, I was about 120lbs (about 55kg). So as you can see, pretty light for a guy. These days I'm about 160lbs (about 73kg).
Like (0)
Posted on Aug 25, 2014, 11:13 pm
#4
Quote from: tapemeasure on August 25, 2014, 10:22:01 PM
I already have quite a long thread in this forum already, but I wanted to ask this specific question in a separate thread.

I was having a discussion with my parents about eating and the subject got onto breakfast. I regularly would never have any breakfast, between the ages of about 12 and 18. During the school day, my lunch consisted of a few sandwiches, a bag of crisps and some biscuits/some chocolate. I'm actually amazed I could concentrate at school. Evening meals would vary but usually a decent sized portion with meat and some carbs. So I regularly went from 7pm one day, to 12pm the next day without any food. I also didn't drink milk during these years either, nor would I eat many (if any) fruit and veg, if that's any relevance.

Your body obviously gets accustomed to a pattern. At the time, I don't remember feeling that bad, but maybe I was a bit under-nourished? Maybe it affected my growth? My parents don't think it caused any loss of growth. They said they encouraged me to eat breakfast but I didn't want to, and they didn't force me. I've even asked a doctor before but they said I fall within the average range so it's no concern (also they said there's no way of knowing if I could have grown more).

Honestly how much do you think something like this affected my growth? Even if it didn't necessarily affect my height, could it have affected other areas? Any other information you need, feel free to ask. How much do you think this affected my growth?

Holy s**t. Exactly the same you wrote could've came from myself. I too was somewhat thin during many years in puberty, and I too skipped breakfast during the week, and I too blame my parents for that. Adding to that, I'm a guy who naturally stays up late and gets up late, but during my school years I had to get up early, so I slept until the last minute and then rushed to school, without having eaten anything. On top of that, my parents were divorced so it was just me and my mom or my dad living together, so there was no breakfast table where the whole family eats together in the morning, which is probably usual for normal families. Like you I didn't feel any bad during those years, I never suffered hunger, but as you said, the body adapts to many situations.

All I can tell you is that your parents/your doctor are right: There is no way of knowing if or how much this affected your growth, and every doctor will confirm this. Everybody's body type is different and it's really hard to tell if something was wrong in the past. All you can do is make estimates and guesses, but you will never know for sure. Which, logically means: Stop making yourself crazy and stop thinking about it - I know that's hard, because I can't stop thinking about it either. If you ask me, I say it couldn't have a big effect, because you weren't suffering hunger or malnutrition.
Like (0)
Posted on Aug 25, 2014, 11:16 pm
#5
Quote from: theuprising on August 25, 2014, 10:28:00 PM
To stunt growth you have to be malnourished. Think skinny kids with bones showing type malnourished.
You were fine.

That's funny because I remember at one occasion during my early teenage years, I was standing infront of the mirror in the bathroom, and I was stretching, and you could really see a few of the upper rips shining through my torso. It looked scary. But I never suffered hunger!
Like (0)
Posted on Aug 26, 2014, 1:27 am
#6
Quote from: tapemeasure on August 25, 2014, 10:37:32 PM
For what it's worth, I remember getting weighed at age 15 - I was only 105 lbs (about 48kg). At 17, I was about 120lbs (about 55kg). So as you can see, pretty light for a guy. These days I'm about 160lbs (about 73kg).

About how tall were you at age 12?

How much height did you gain from ages 12-15?

How much height did you gain from ages 15-18?

How much height did you gain after age 18?

If you answer these questions, we can have a better idea of if your growth pattern was abnormal and thus make an educated guess as to whether or not you stunted your growth.
Like (0)
Posted on Aug 26, 2014, 2:27 am
#7
Your height would only be affected if you were severely malnourished on a third world country level. Not having breakfast wouldn't bring you to that point.
Like (0)
Posted on Aug 26, 2014, 3:35 am
#8
Quote from: KiloKAHN on August 26, 2014, 02:27:34 AM
Your height would only be affected if you were severely malnourished on a third world country level. Not having breakfast wouldn't bring you to that point.

I'm actually laughing that they think this.  How much do you think this affected my growth?

Height is purely genetics if you're not being malnourished.  Don't worry about the past, focus on the present.
Like (0)
Posted on Aug 26, 2014, 4:18 am
#9
I think it's pretty frustrating reading something from different members and we know nothing about their height.

They could be 5'9 for what we know.

If you were 55kg and 5'5 then you were okey. Maybe even a bit chubby.

If you were 55kg and 5'11 then you either were in extreme on petition class or most definitely malnourished.
Like (0)
Posted on Aug 26, 2014, 4:20 am
#10
Thats funny because I used to blame my mom that I ate bad. I would eat a bowl of pasta for dinner usually. Bad to eat before bed especially refined flour cuz it interferes with ur body releasing gh. Plus I slept with the tv on from like 5-15 lol so i probably never got deep sleep although it would turn off by itself a few hours into sleep. I would eat candy every day, no veggies or fruits. I wasn't malnourised tho because I went to the doctor and had tests done. one time my iron was low but we fixed that. Anyway I am 5'3 7/8th and my mom is 5'5 and dad is 5'9 so the foot must have had something to do with it.
Like (0)

You must be logged in to post a reply.

Related Topics

How much can i lengthen, with pics
oeioei2 16 replies • 2 seconds ago
Life's a joke and I need advice
Girl22 10 replies • 5 seconds ago
Should I lengthen with a short torso?
Kraken 33 replies • 6 seconds ago
This is why you shouldn’t worry about proportions.
PossibleFutureLLer 1 replies • 7 seconds ago
5'10" 86.5 cm sitting height
deletedaccount 10 replies • 7 seconds ago